BSRLM

British Society for Research into Learning Mathematics

  • Home
  • About
    • Who We Are
    • Solidarity Fund
    • Constitution
    • AGM Papers and Minutes
    • Leone Burton Fund
    • Janet Duffin Fund, Award and Lecture
    • BERA Special Interest Group on Mathematics in Education
    • Copyright statement
  • Publications
    • Proceedings of BSRLM day conferences
    • Research in Mathematics Education
    • BCME Conference Proceedings and Occasional publications
    • BSRLM Conference Proceedings Template
  • Events
    • Future Conferences
    • Working Groups
    • New Researchers’ Day
    • BERA SIG Events
    • Previous Conferences
    • Gallery
    • Conference Keynotes
  • Members
    • Members’ area
    • Become a member of BSRLM
  • News
  • blogs
  • Contact Us
  • Log In

BSRLM Proceedings: Vol 18 No 3 November 1998

Proceedings of the Day Conference held at School of Education, University of Leeds, November 1998

PLEASE NOTE: These IPs have been scanned and reconstituted from the printed versions. Although the pagination has been maintained, there may be some odd discrepancies from the original – if anything is glaringly wrong or misleading please let our webmaster know with a correction, full details of the paper, page and sufficient detail to locate the error.

Contents

1 Kenneth Lovell (1915 -1996): Methodist and Pioneer in Mathematics Education Research

Anthony Orton
University of Leeds

2 Routine Questions and A-Level Mathematics Grades

This study concerns student performance in A-level examination questions. In particular whether lower attaining students in mathematics examinations generally gain their marks on routine parts of questions? Students’ scripts in a recent mathematics examination were examined in an attempt to evaluate this question. The question is an important one because routine questions could be awarded fewer marks if algebraic calculators are allowed in examinations. The results are not conclusive but indicate that a problem of this type does exist.

John Berry and Wendy Maull, University of Plymouth
Peter Johnson and John Monaghan, University of Leeds

3 Developing Algebra – A Case Study of the First Lessons from the Beginning of Year 7

This is a case study from the start of a project, funded by the Training and Development Agency For Schools (ITA), looking at one mixed ability year 7 class in a Bristol comprehensive, investigating what algebra is taught and what algebra is learnt over the period of their first term at secondary school. The motivation for the study is to explore the challenge inherent in the quote: ‘Can we develop a school algebra culture in which pupils find a need for algebraic symbolism to express and explore their mathematical ideas?’ (Sutherland 1991). We see the role of the teacher as that of setting up a ‘community of practice’ (Lave and Wenger 1991) in the classroom, where the practice is that of ‘inquiry’ (Schoenfeld, 1996). Resultsfrom the first seven lessons with the group are presented and analysed, setting up further research questions.

Alf Coles, Kingsfield School
Laurinda Brown, University of Bristol Graduate School of Education

4 The Role of the Semiotic Representations in the Learning of Mathematics

We argue that mathematics visualisation and the construction of concepts require the coordination of different representations that belong to different semiotic systems of representations. Unsuitable construction of a concept will impede the acquisition of more abstract conceptualisation. In this context, we will discuss about cognitive obstacles which some teachers and students have when facing mathematical problems related to precalculus and calculus topics. Mathematics visualisation in this context deals with an holistic vision that articulates several representations in a problem solving situation.

Fernando Hitt
University of Nottingham

5 Do KS3 SATs Testfor Qualitatively Different Forms of Mathematical Understanding

Here I present case studies of individual pupils who, whilst achieving the same SATs levels, seem to display different forms of understanding of mathematics. This raises the question about whether KS3 SATs distinguish between procedural and conceptual understanding, as was originally intended.

Andrea Lowe
University of Warwick

6 Mental Models of Force and Motion in 11 to 18 Year Olds

Previous studies have suggested that students may compartmentalise knowledge: their everyday intuitions will serve in everyday contexts and their academic knowledge is activated, if ever, in academic contexts. In this study we put forward a case where significant numbers of students of Newtonian theory provide mixed explanations of motion in the same context. They typically switch from one model to another depending on the values of the masses and forces involved.

Peter Mildenhall
University of Manchester and Bury Grammar School

7 The Research of Ideas of Probability in the Elementary Level of Education

Ideas of probability have been investigated in Mexican elementary education.
Two examples are given to illustrate the way in which epistemological aspects are considered in this research. Teaching experiments with 6-7 year old children suggest that pupils’ interpretations of the tasks they were asked about may result in answers which do not inform on their idea of chance, since they tend not to focus on it. Additionally, by using questionnaires and clinical interviews with 10-15 year old children, it was found that their correct handling of fractions does not assure that they can cope with questions about probability for which a quantification would suppose fraction use.

Ana-Maria Ojeda
University of Nottingham

8 Key Stage 3 Statutory Assessment 1998 – Report on an ATUATM/NATE Joint Study

The Key Stage 3 tests in mathematics are now well established, and QCA ‘ s annual evaluations suggest that they are generally well regarded. In this study, initiated by the curriculum committee of the Association of Teachers and Lecturers, the views of teachers suggest that whilst the tests for mathematics are broadly accepted, there are still a number of issues that need to be addressed: compatibility with GCSE, transparency about which level of attainment each question targets, mental mathematics (time for questions, differentiated papers), how returned scripts are used and the status of teacher assessment.

Sue Pope
Roehampton Institute, London

9 A Critique of Relativism in Mathematics Education: The Needfor an Objectivist Perspective ifwe are to Facilitate Cognitive Growth

Many constructivists tag as ‘absolutist’ references to mathematics as a body of knowledge, and stake-out the moral high-ground with the argument that mathematics is not only utilised oppressively but that it is, in-itself, oppressive. With much reference to Paul Ernest’s (1991) Philosophy of Mathematics Education this tag has been justified on the grounds that ifmathematics is a social-cultural creation that is mutable and fallible then it must be social acceptance that confers the objectivity of mathematics. I will argue that mathematics is a body of knowledge the objectivity of which is independent of origin or social acceptance. Recently, Paul Ernest ( 1998) has attempted to include the category of logical necessity in his elaboration of the objectivity of mathematics. I will argue that this inclusion of logical necessity not only represents a V-turn, but that the way in which Ernest has included this category is an attempt to maintain his earlier position that it is social acceptance that confers the objectivity of mathematics.

Stuart Rowlands
University of Plymouth

10 Distributed Cognition, Computers and the Interpretation of Graphs

One aspect of recent research on students’ understanding of graphs in computer and in pencil and paper media is reported on. Over 200 Year 10 students in two comprehensive schools in Leeds participated in a teaching experiment, 100+ with and 100+ without the use of computers. Pre/post-tests and interviews provide data for a comparison of learning with the two media. The wider study examines students’ construction and interpretation of context graphs (related to situations) and context free graphs (x-y graphs). This paper concentrates on students’ interpretation of context free graphs.

Pumadevi Sivasubramaniam
University of Leeds

11 Children’s Understanding of Number Patterns

This article deals with children’s reactions when they are confronted with problems concerning number patterns. In German schools, problems concerning patterns and number patterns are rare, some curricula do not even mention them.

Therefore my documented tests are the first contact with these problems for most children. This is also a big opportunity for my research, because the aim is to show the genuine reactions of the children. The main topic of this article will be some results of a school-project with 9 to 10-year olds.

Anna Susanne Steinweg
University of Dortmund, Germany

12 Are Mental Calculation Strategies Really Strategies?

Some of the approaches used by children when calculating involve a flexible and inferential use of number knowledge. These approaches are often called “strategies”, and it is a reasonable ambition for teaching to enhance children’s skill in this area. But what exactly does effective performance of this kind involve? This paper considers to what extent children’s calculation
‘strategies’ are really strategic, and explores the viability of teaching mental calculation through direct instruction in “strategies”.

John Threlfall
University of Leeds

13 Mental Calculation Strategies Employed by Teacher-Trainee Students

First year student teachers were asked to mentally solve different types of addition and subtraction problems typically found in mental arithmetic practice tests. Subsequently they were asked to describe how they found the answers, in terms of figuring skills such as counting-on, counting-back, counting-up, using number bonds etc. The student replies were analysed and classified according to which figuring skills were applied to which type of problem. Summaries of these figuring skills applied to the decontextualised question numbers were also demonstrated diagrammatically.

David Womack
University Manchester

14 Geometry Working Group

This report focuses on the use of imagery to solve a range of spatial problems. The research projects reviewed in this report offer some insight into the range of strategies used by solvers of spatial problems and point to relationships between spatial and verbal skills.

Convenor: Keith Jones
University of Southampton

15 Advanced Mathematical Thinking Working Group

The last session highlighted an interest in the idea of the procept in elementary mathematical thinking and its possible use in transfer to advanced mathematical thinking (AMT). This session set out to analyse the paper by Gray and Tall (1994), to enlighten the group’s understanding of the idea and its consequences. The group offered mixed reactions towards the paper and advanced mathematical thinking as a genre. This paper highlights the main themes of the paper, the reactions of the group and future ideas for discussion.

Stephen Hegedus
University of Southampton

16 Primary Student Teachers’ Understanding of Mathematics and Its Teaching: A Preliminary Report

The research set out to investigate the ways in which non-specialist student teachers conceptualise mathematics and its teaching and how their views evolve as they progress through an initial training course.

Tony Brown, Una Hanley, Liz Jones, Olwen McNamara
Manchester Metropolitan University

17 Research Report on the Classroom Implementation of the Socratic Method in Mechanics

Following twenty years of international research into student ‘misconceptions’ offorce and motion, there is an ongoing debate about how to improve student understanding in mechanics. Following recent research into the Socratic method for overcoming misconceptions in mechanics, this research is now continuing in the classroom to evaluate the effectiveness of, and to refine, the method. At this stage of the research, the Socratic method is being developed with a view to creating a strategy for handling intuitive responses to concept questions. After an initial classroom session and a series of individual interviews with a particular series of Socratic questions, the responses were considered and the questions refined before further taped interviews. In this session we will report on initial work carried out within the topic of projectile motion. We will then discuss some of the issues raised in attempting to develop this approach.

Kathy Green, Maxine Mercer, Peter McWilliam and Stuart Rowlands
University of Plymouth

18 Cabri as a Cognitive Tool

The main aim of this paper is to analyse the role of Cabri-Geometre (Baulac, Bellemain & Laborde, 1988) as a cognitive tool in the teaching and learning of mathematics.

Catia Mogetta
University of Bristol Graduate School of Education

19 Misconceptions of Modelling in Mechanics: A Review of the Recent A-Level Textbooks in Mechanics

A-level boards have included a modelling approach in the syllabus of their respective mechanics modules, and the recent plethora of textbooks, including those that represent the various exam boards (e.g. AEB, London, MEI), are structured according to this approach. This session will review the many recent A -level textbooks in mechanics that have included a modelling approach, and will attempt to show that these books are confused as to what modelling in mechanics actually is and the possible pedagogical consequences.

Stuart Rowlands
University of Plymouth

Our Aim

BSRLM is for people interested in research in mathematics education and provides a supportive and inclusive environment for both new and experienced researchers to develop their ideas.

Become a Member

Members of BSRLM can attend and present at our termly Day Conferences. You will also receive the three annual issues of Research in Mathematics Education published for BSRLM by Taylor and Francis.
Join BSRLM

Social

  • E-mail
  • Twitter

Latest Updates

BSRLM Follow

BSRLM is a national organisation for people who are passionate about mathematics education research. RTs are not endorsements. Posts by K Skilling

BSRLM_maths
bsrlm_maths BSRLM @bsrlm_maths ·
16 Oct

Looking forward to the next BSRLM day conference at the University of Southampton- November 2nd 📢

Reply on Twitter 1846476717973463051 Retweet on Twitter 1846476717973463051 3 Like on Twitter 1846476717973463051 5 Twitter 1846476717973463051
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
rme_resmathed RME Journal @rme_resmathed ·
28 Aug

https://doi.org/10.1080/14794802.2024.2382459
Article online now 📷 “The evaluation of computational modelling performance within the context of rationality theory: finding the area between two curves” by Selin Urhan
@BSRLM_maths

#iTeachMath #MathsEd #Maths #Research

Reply on Twitter 1828715644768112964 Retweet on Twitter 1828715644768112964 1 Like on Twitter 1828715644768112964 1 Twitter 1828715644768112964
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
rme_resmathed RME Journal @rme_resmathed ·
7 Oct

https://doi.org/10.1080/14794802.2024.2379301
Article online now 📷 “Investigating insight and rigour as separate constructs in mathematical proof” by C. J. Sangwin & George Kinnear
@BSRLM_maths

#iTeachMath #MathsEd #Maths #Research #OpenAccess

Reply on Twitter 1843212417779536249 Retweet on Twitter 1843212417779536249 1 Like on Twitter 1843212417779536249 2 Twitter 1843212417779536249
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
rme_resmathed RME Journal @rme_resmathed ·
9 Oct

https://doi.org/10.1080/14794802.2024.2388064
Article online now 📷 “Reinterpreting the numerical discourse: a commognitive study of teachers’ support of students’ transition into the proving discourse” by Sigrid Iversen Klock
@BSRLM_maths

#iTeachMath #MathsEd #Maths #Research #OpenAccess

Reply on Twitter 1843937697049841980 Retweet on Twitter 1843937697049841980 1 Like on Twitter 1843937697049841980 Twitter 1843937697049841980
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
rme_resmathed RME Journal @rme_resmathed ·
11 Oct

https://doi.org/10.1080/14794802.2024.2388067
Article online now 📷 “Comparing contrasting instructional approaches: a way for research to develop insights about backward transfer” by Charles Hohensee, Sara Gartland, Matthew Melville & Laura Willoughby
@BSRLM_maths

#MathsEd #Maths #Research

Reply on Twitter 1844662976110104962 Retweet on Twitter 1844662976110104962 1 Like on Twitter 1844662976110104962 Twitter 1844662976110104962
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
rme_resmathed RME Journal @rme_resmathed ·
14 Oct

https://doi.org/10.1080/14794802.2024.2401484
Article online now 📷 “Immigrant students’ experiences of (Re)producing school mathematics in home-School transitions – epistemological positioning” by Ulrika Ryan & P. S. Källberg
@BSRLM_maths
#MathsEd #Maths #Research #OpenAccess

Reply on Twitter 1845736802206073149 Retweet on Twitter 1845736802206073149 1 Like on Twitter 1845736802206073149 3 Twitter 1845736802206073149
bsrlm_maths BSRLM @bsrlm_maths ·
4 Oct

Save the date for the next BSRLM conference - Sat 2nd November at the University of Southampton 📢

Reply on Twitter 1842073254887932206 Retweet on Twitter 1842073254887932206 5 Like on Twitter 1842073254887932206 4 Twitter 1842073254887932206
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
drhelendrury Helen Drury @drhelendrury ·
6 Jun

Only one more sleep until @BSRLM_maths conference at @LboroDME 🏫👩‍🏫

Who else is excited?!

@TFrancome @MarkBoylanEd @SmartJacques @USaad @Iro_XD @colinfoster77 @VolodymyrProsh @mathsacharya @B_Woollacott @sheard_simon @Tassaara

Reply on Twitter 1798713741854523421 Retweet on Twitter 1798713741854523421 5 Like on Twitter 1798713741854523421 18 Twitter 1798713741854523421
bsrlm_maths BSRLM @bsrlm_maths ·
7 Jun

Interesting and stimulating discussion at the Mathematics Education and Policy Working Group @BSRLM_maths - summer conference @SmartJacques @MarkBoylanEd @GillRAdams @AlfColes

Reply on Twitter 1799036016055173391 Retweet on Twitter 1799036016055173391 2 Like on Twitter 1799036016055173391 4 Twitter 1799036016055173391
bsrlm_maths BSRLM @bsrlm_maths ·
26 May

Don't forget to register for the BSRLM summer conference and New Researchers' Day taking place 7th and 8th June - registration closes 31st May. (Committee @AlfColes @CristinaMio11 @MandyLLiu1 @OuhaoC @SmartJacques @karen_skilling)

Reply on Twitter 1794582210403602625 Retweet on Twitter 1794582210403602625 4 Like on Twitter 1794582210403602625 4 Twitter 1794582210403602625
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
oxunimaths Oxford Mathematics @oxunimaths ·
10 May 2024

The newly created UK-wide Academy for the Mathematical Sciences today appointed Oxford Mathematician Alison Etheridge as its first President.

The Academy's focus will be on mathematical sciences everywhere: in teaching & education, academic research, & business & government.

Reply on Twitter 1788859653448736981 Retweet on Twitter 1788859653448736981 39 Like on Twitter 1788859653448736981 173 Twitter 1788859653448736981
bsrlm_maths BSRLM @bsrlm_maths ·
22 Apr 2024

The next BSRLM conference will be our Summer conference on the 7th and 8th June at Loughborough University. Please use this link to find out about registration and the call for session proposals. https://www.bsrlm-members.org.uk/pages/15-conferences

Reply on Twitter 1782402985768685723 Retweet on Twitter 1782402985768685723 6 Like on Twitter 1782402985768685723 4 Twitter 1782402985768685723
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
scottishmaths SMC @scottishmaths ·
10 Mar 2024

CALL for PRESENTERS: SMC Stirling Maths Conference Saturday 18th May 2024. Open to all from across early years, primary, secondary and tertiary education. Fill in this form by **14 March 2024** https://forms.office.com/e/iPHkKqME0E

Reply on Twitter 1766898905394848114 Retweet on Twitter 1766898905394848114 14 Like on Twitter 1766898905394848114 8 Twitter 1766898905394848114
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
rme_resmathed RME Journal @rme_resmathed ·
28 Feb 2024

https://doi.org/10.1080/14794802.2024.2306928
Article online now 📷 “Teacher identities and teacher identity change in pre-service mathematics teachers’ metaphors” by Okan Arslan and Çiğdem Haser
@BSRLM_maths
#iTeachMath #MathsEd #Maths #Research

Reply on Twitter 1762768351758274726 Retweet on Twitter 1762768351758274726 1 Like on Twitter 1762768351758274726 3 Twitter 1762768351758274726
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
rme_resmathed RME Journal @rme_resmathed ·
1 Mar 2024

https://doi.org/10.1080/14794802.2024.2306633
Article online now 📷 “The impact of realistic mathematics education on secondary school students’ problem-solving skills: a comparative evaluation study” by Georgios Ventistas, Ourania Maria Ventista & Paraskevi Tsani
@BSRLM_maths
#MathsEd #Research

Reply on Twitter 1763493630218801441 Retweet on Twitter 1763493630218801441 3 Like on Twitter 1763493630218801441 2 Twitter 1763493630218801441
bsrlm_maths BSRLM @bsrlm_maths ·
1 Mar 2024

Looking forward to meeting up online tomorrow at our Spring Conference...choose your sessions

Reply on Twitter 1763552009200759220 Retweet on Twitter 1763552009200759220 1 Like on Twitter 1763552009200759220 2 Twitter 1763552009200759220
bsrlm_maths BSRLM @bsrlm_maths ·
5 Feb 2024

Professor Jodie Hunter will be the plenary speaker at our online conference on Saturday 3rd March. Please use this link to register and submit a proposal https://www.bsrlm-members.org.uk/pages/15-conferences

Reply on Twitter 1754399410014880174 Retweet on Twitter 1754399410014880174 4 Like on Twitter 1754399410014880174 8 Twitter 1754399410014880174
bsrlm_maths BSRLM @bsrlm_maths ·
16 Jan 2024

Happy New Year to all members. Please note that our next conference will take place via zoom on Saturday 2nd March. Registration for session proposals are open - click here for more details https://bsrlm-members.org.uk/pages/15-conferences…@BSRLM_maths

Reply on Twitter 1747108128573751584 Retweet on Twitter 1747108128573751584 4 Like on Twitter 1747108128573751584 4 Twitter 1747108128573751584
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
londmathsoc London Mathematical Society @londmathsoc ·
8 Dec 2023

The 2023-24 Round of LMS Early Career Fellowships are live, open to early career mathematicians in the transition between PhD and a postdoctoral position.

For further details ➡️ https://www.lms.ac.uk/grants/lms-early-career-fellowships

Reply on Twitter 1733166301923738025 Retweet on Twitter 1733166301923738025 11 Like on Twitter 1733166301923738025 14 Twitter 1733166301923738025
bsrlm_maths BSRLM @bsrlm_maths ·
8 Dec 2023

We already have some interest for this Special Issue @RME_ResMathEd and the call for abstracts is open for another week so please consider making a submission Call for Special Issue 2025 Abstracts💡 https://bsrlm.org.uk/call-for-papers-for-the-2025-special-issue-of-research-in-mathematics-education-rme-contemporary-issues-in-mathematics-education-within-a-stem-climate/… Send an Abstract to rme@bsrlm.org.uk by 15th Dec 2023

Reply on Twitter 1733172582793330723 Retweet on Twitter 1733172582793330723 4 Like on Twitter 1733172582793330723 2 Twitter 1733172582793330723
Load More

Contact

Chair:
Alf Coles
Secretary:
Laurie Jacques
Treasurer:
Dave Hewitt
Membership Coordinator:
Rosa Archer


Outreach Coordinator:
Ouhao Chen
Publications Officer:
Taro Fujita
Day Conference Organisers:
Cristina Mio and Bohan Liu
Online Communications Coordinator:
Karen Skilling

© Copyright 2023 BSRLM · All Rights Reserved · All Logos & Trademark Belongs To Their Respective Owners · Web Design Agency - Bowler Hat