BSRLM

British Society for Research into Learning Mathematics

  • Home
  • About
    • Who We Are
    • Solidarity Fund
    • Constitution
    • AGM Papers and Minutes
    • Leone Burton Fund
    • Janet Duffin Fund, Award and Lecture
    • BERA Special Interest Group on Mathematics in Education
    • Copyright statement
  • Publications
    • Proceedings of BSRLM day conferences
    • Research in Mathematics Education
    • BCME Conference Proceedings and Occasional publications
    • BSRLM Conference Proceedings Template
  • Events
    • Future Conferences
    • Working Groups
    • New Researchers’ Day
    • BERA SIG Events
    • Previous Conferences
    • Gallery
    • Conference Keynotes
  • Members
    • Members’ area
    • Become a member of BSRLM
  • News
  • blogs
  • Contact Us
  • Log In

Using self-video within teacher and researcher collaborative research

17th October 2017 by Karen Skilling

One of a series of blogs on ‘building and sustaining active research collaborations with teachers of mathematics’

Written by Jenni Ingram and Nick Andrews:

Collaborative research within education is both rewarding and complex.  The Talk in Mathematics project involved two groups of maths teachers and some colleagues at the university working together on developing students’ talk in lessons. In this blog post we explore the way the collaboration worked, how and why this collaboration evolved and adapted in many unanticipated ways as the roles of the different participants and their respective expertise were negotiated.

As researchers, our aim from the start was that there would be no expertise that was valued over another and no role that was emphasised over another.  All those involved are teaching or have taught mathematics in comprehensive schools; have worked on developing other teachers’ practices, both experienced teachers and beginning teachers; have conducted classroom-based research, and have worked in research teams. The divide between teacher and researcher is not in any way clear.  Each member of the group draws upon different experiences of teaching and learning and the vision was these differences would strengthen and enable practice to develop further, and it has!

We met several times a year to share video clips of teaching and explore issues that arose in teaching that related to developing students’ language use. The motivations for attending these meetings were multifaceted.  Some are involved because they want to improve students’ mathematical discourse, some are involved because they feel they ought to be, some are looking for ‘expert’ input, some are looking for new ideas, some are there because it is part of their performance management targets, some are there to collect data for research.   Whilst all of these motivations enable the goals of the project to be achieved, there is a need to balance these different motivations in how we work together.

Pausing

Teachers know their students and their experiences of learning mathematics and this expertise is vital in any collaborative research.  Teachers are also taking risks whenever they alter their practice and can often understand some of the more subtle differences that result from any change that can be missed by others. Teachers are also balancing many different demands which they need to consider when collaborating in research.  All of these aspects can make the research stronger, and the results more meaningful to teachers, surely key priorities for any research with teachers.

When we met one or two teachers chose a short clip (2-3 mins) from a video of their own teaching that they had recorded themselves that contained something that interested them.  Sometimes this was something they had deliberately changed about their practice that they wanted to explore further.  Sometimes it was something problematic that they wanted to work on and find ways to adapt their practice.  The teacher would show the clip and then describe what they noticed and what interested them.  The clip was then watched and re-watched and discussed as a group, where we noticed things we had not noticed before and explored variations and possibilities that could be explored in practice.

Within these meetings there was some negotiation of roles.  Some teachers were actively seeking advice about what to do, positioning themselves as someone who was learning how to teach and positioning others as having the answers.  Other teachers focused on sharing aspects of their practice that they saw as ‘good’ teaching or asking questions that might prompt reflection. The aim of the group was not to give advice or make judgements but to explore possibilities and decisions that could be made.

Representing turns in talk

The focus for the meeting was often set by the person sharing a clip and this was sometimes shared in advance. But at other times the focus arose from the discussions, particularly when something was noticed that interested the group but was not what had motivated the choice of the clip.  One of the researchers would use this focus to devise a prompt or task following the discussion about the clip to shift attention to each teacher thinking about their own teaching and opportunities and possibilities to develop their practice further.  Again, this task rested on the different sources of expertise in the group to explore these opportunities and possibilities.

The nature of the collaboration in this project is underpinned by our values as researchers.  We saw teachers as being the experts in teaching, having the knowledge and understanding of their own practice and of their own students.  Our role as researchers was to provide opportunities, prompts, and time for these teachers to work together on changing their practice.  The use of self-video and the regular meetings can be viewed as an intervention but the changes that arose in the classroom resulted from the decisions that the teachers themselves made.  This way of working enabled a certain authenticity to how research findings can be put into practice in classrooms.  We did not explicitly share research findings at any point, but the teachers made suggestions and reached conclusions that resonate with the research into classroom interaction but also enabled us all to explore different practices in more depth and with more nuance than can be done through the reading of research findings.

Jenni Ingram works at the University of Oxford, Department of Education:
@IngramJenni; jenni.ingram@education.ox.ac.uk

Nick Andrews works at the University of Oxford, Department of Education:
Nicholas.Andrews@education.ox.ac.uk

Filed Under: blogs Tagged With: classroom based research, collaborative research, talk in mathematics, video

Our Aim

BSRLM is for people interested in research in mathematics education and provides a supportive and inclusive environment for both new and experienced researchers to develop their ideas.

Become a Member

Members of BSRLM can attend and present at our termly Day Conferences. You will also receive the three annual issues of Research in Mathematics Education published for BSRLM by Taylor and Francis.
Join BSRLM

Social

  • E-mail
  • Twitter

Latest Updates

BSRLM Follow

BSRLM is a national organisation for people who are passionate about mathematics education research. RTs are not endorsements. Posts by K Skilling

BSRLM_maths
bsrlm_maths BSRLM @bsrlm_maths ·
16 Oct

Looking forward to the next BSRLM day conference at the University of Southampton- November 2nd 📢

Reply on Twitter 1846476717973463051 Retweet on Twitter 1846476717973463051 3 Like on Twitter 1846476717973463051 4 Twitter 1846476717973463051
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
rme_resmathed RME Journal @rme_resmathed ·
28 Aug


Article online now 📷 “The evaluation of computational modelling performance within the context of rationality theory: finding the area between two curves” by Selin Urhan
@BSRLM_maths

#iTeachMath #MathsEd #Maths #Research

Reply on Twitter 1828715644768112964 Retweet on Twitter 1828715644768112964 1 Like on Twitter 1828715644768112964 1 Twitter 1828715644768112964
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
rme_resmathed RME Journal @rme_resmathed ·
7 Oct


Article online now 📷 “Investigating insight and rigour as separate constructs in mathematical proof” by C. J. Sangwin & George Kinnear
@BSRLM_maths

#iTeachMath #MathsEd #Maths #Research #OpenAccess

Reply on Twitter 1843212417779536249 Retweet on Twitter 1843212417779536249 1 Like on Twitter 1843212417779536249 2 Twitter 1843212417779536249
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
rme_resmathed RME Journal @rme_resmathed ·
9 Oct


Article online now 📷 “Reinterpreting the numerical discourse: a commognitive study of teachers’ support of students’ transition into the proving discourse” by Sigrid Iversen Klock
@BSRLM_maths

#iTeachMath #MathsEd #Maths #Research #OpenAccess

Reply on Twitter 1843937697049841980 Retweet on Twitter 1843937697049841980 1 Like on Twitter 1843937697049841980 Twitter 1843937697049841980
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
rme_resmathed RME Journal @rme_resmathed ·
11 Oct


Article online now 📷 “Comparing contrasting instructional approaches: a way for research to develop insights about backward transfer” by Charles Hohensee, Sara Gartland, Matthew Melville & Laura Willoughby
@BSRLM_maths

#MathsEd #Maths #Research

Reply on Twitter 1844662976110104962 Retweet on Twitter 1844662976110104962 1 Like on Twitter 1844662976110104962 Twitter 1844662976110104962
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
rme_resmathed RME Journal @rme_resmathed ·
14 Oct


Article online now 📷 “Immigrant students’ experiences of (Re)producing school mathematics in home-School transitions – epistemological positioning” by Ulrika Ryan & P. S. Källberg
@BSRLM_maths
#MathsEd #Maths #Research #OpenAccess

Reply on Twitter 1845736802206073149 Retweet on Twitter 1845736802206073149 1 Like on Twitter 1845736802206073149 3 Twitter 1845736802206073149
bsrlm_maths BSRLM @bsrlm_maths ·
4 Oct

Save the date for the next BSRLM conference - Sat 2nd November at the University of Southampton 📢

Reply on Twitter 1842073254887932206 Retweet on Twitter 1842073254887932206 5 Like on Twitter 1842073254887932206 4 Twitter 1842073254887932206
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
drhelendrury Helen Drury @drhelendrury ·
6 Jun

Only one more sleep until @BSRLM_maths conference at @LboroDME 🏫👩‍🏫

Who else is excited?!

@TFrancome @MarkBoylanEd @SmartJacques @USaad @Iro_XD @colinfoster77 @VolodymyrProsh @mathsacharya @B_Woollacott @sheard_simon @Tassaara

Reply on Twitter 1798713741854523421 Retweet on Twitter 1798713741854523421 5 Like on Twitter 1798713741854523421 18 Twitter 1798713741854523421
bsrlm_maths BSRLM @bsrlm_maths ·
7 Jun

Interesting and stimulating discussion at the Mathematics Education and Policy Working Group @BSRLM_maths - summer conference @SmartJacques @MarkBoylanEd @GillRAdams @AlfColes

Reply on Twitter 1799036016055173391 Retweet on Twitter 1799036016055173391 2 Like on Twitter 1799036016055173391 3 Twitter 1799036016055173391
bsrlm_maths BSRLM @bsrlm_maths ·
26 May

Don't forget to register for the BSRLM summer conference and New Researchers' Day taking place 7th and 8th June - registration closes 31st May. (Committee @AlfColes @CristinaMio11 @MandyLLiu1 @OuhaoC @SmartJacques @karen_skilling)

Reply on Twitter 1794582210403602625 Retweet on Twitter 1794582210403602625 4 Like on Twitter 1794582210403602625 4 Twitter 1794582210403602625
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
oxunimaths Oxford Mathematics @oxunimaths ·
10 May 2024

The newly created UK-wide Academy for the Mathematical Sciences today appointed Oxford Mathematician Alison Etheridge as its first President.

The Academy's focus will be on mathematical sciences everywhere: in teaching & education, academic research, & business & government.

Reply on Twitter 1788859653448736981 Retweet on Twitter 1788859653448736981 38 Like on Twitter 1788859653448736981 172 Twitter 1788859653448736981
bsrlm_maths BSRLM @bsrlm_maths ·
22 Apr 2024

The next BSRLM conference will be our Summer conference on the 7th and 8th June at Loughborough University. Please use this link to find out about registration and the call for session proposals.

Reply on Twitter 1782402985768685723 Retweet on Twitter 1782402985768685723 6 Like on Twitter 1782402985768685723 4 Twitter 1782402985768685723
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
scottishmaths SMC @scottishmaths ·
10 Mar 2024

CALL for PRESENTERS: SMC Stirling Maths Conference Saturday 18th May 2024. Open to all from across early years, primary, secondary and tertiary education. Fill in this form by **14 March 2024**

Reply on Twitter 1766898905394848114 Retweet on Twitter 1766898905394848114 12 Like on Twitter 1766898905394848114 6 Twitter 1766898905394848114
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
rme_resmathed RME Journal @rme_resmathed ·
28 Feb 2024


Article online now 📷 “Teacher identities and teacher identity change in pre-service mathematics teachers’ metaphors” by Okan Arslan and Çiğdem Haser
@BSRLM_maths
#iTeachMath #MathsEd #Maths #Research

Reply on Twitter 1762768351758274726 Retweet on Twitter 1762768351758274726 1 Like on Twitter 1762768351758274726 3 Twitter 1762768351758274726
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
rme_resmathed RME Journal @rme_resmathed ·
1 Mar 2024


Article online now 📷 “The impact of realistic mathematics education on secondary school students’ problem-solving skills: a comparative evaluation study” by Georgios Ventistas, Ourania Maria Ventista & Paraskevi Tsani
@BSRLM_maths
#MathsEd #Research

Reply on Twitter 1763493630218801441 Retweet on Twitter 1763493630218801441 3 Like on Twitter 1763493630218801441 2 Twitter 1763493630218801441
bsrlm_maths BSRLM @bsrlm_maths ·
1 Mar 2024

Looking forward to meeting up online tomorrow at our Spring Conference...choose your sessions

Reply on Twitter 1763552009200759220 Retweet on Twitter 1763552009200759220 1 Like on Twitter 1763552009200759220 2 Twitter 1763552009200759220
bsrlm_maths BSRLM @bsrlm_maths ·
5 Feb 2024

Professor Jodie Hunter will be the plenary speaker at our online conference on Saturday 3rd March. Please use this link to register and submit a proposal https://www.bsrlm-members.org.uk/pages/15-conferences

Reply on Twitter 1754399410014880174 Retweet on Twitter 1754399410014880174 4 Like on Twitter 1754399410014880174 8 Twitter 1754399410014880174
bsrlm_maths BSRLM @bsrlm_maths ·
16 Jan 2024

Happy New Year to all members. Please note that our next conference will take place via zoom on Saturday 2nd March. Registration for session proposals are open - click here for more details https://bsrlm-members.org.uk/pages/15-conferences…@BSRLM_maths

Reply on Twitter 1747108128573751584 Retweet on Twitter 1747108128573751584 4 Like on Twitter 1747108128573751584 4 Twitter 1747108128573751584
Retweet on Twitter BSRLM Retweeted
londmathsoc London Mathematical Society @londmathsoc ·
8 Dec 2023

The 2023-24 Round of LMS Early Career Fellowships are live, open to early career mathematicians in the transition between PhD and a postdoctoral position.

For further details ➡️ https://www.lms.ac.uk/grants/lms-early-career-fellowships

Reply on Twitter 1733166301923738025 Retweet on Twitter 1733166301923738025 11 Like on Twitter 1733166301923738025 14 Twitter 1733166301923738025
bsrlm_maths BSRLM @bsrlm_maths ·
8 Dec 2023

We already have some interest for this Special Issue @RME_ResMathEd and the call for abstracts is open for another week so please consider making a submission Call for Special Issue 2025 Abstracts💡 https://bsrlm.org.uk/call-for-papers-for-the-2025-special-issue-of-research-in-mathematics-education-rme-contemporary-issues-in-mathematics-education-within-a-stem-climate/… Send an Abstract to rme@bsrlm.org.uk by 15th Dec 2023

Reply on Twitter 1733172582793330723 Retweet on Twitter 1733172582793330723 4 Like on Twitter 1733172582793330723 2 Twitter 1733172582793330723
Load More

Contact

Chair:
Alf Coles
Secretary:
Laurie Jacques
Treasurer:
Dave Hewitt
Membership Coordinator:
Rosa Archer


Outreach Coordinator:
Ouhao Chen
Publications Officer:
Taro Fujita
Day Conference Organisers:
Cristina Mio and Bohan Liu
Online Communications Coordinator:
Karen Skilling

© Copyright 2023 BSRLM · All Rights Reserved · All Logos & Trademark Belongs To Their Respective Owners · Web Design Agency - Bowler Hat